Build your retirement plan for free.Explore Plan Builder →

Taxable Account vs. IRA Calculator

Enter your investment amount, contributions, growth rate, and tax rates to see whether a taxable account or IRA (Traditional or Roth) delivers more after-tax wealth over your investment horizon.
Luis GonzalezCreated by Luis GonzalezLast updated:

How to Use This Calculator

  1. 1

    Enter the investment amount and yearly contribution

    Enter the Initial Investment Amount and Annual Contribution. The calculator applies the same deposits to the taxable account and IRA.

  2. 2

    Set the return, time horizon, and tax rates

    Enter the Annual Growth Rate, Investment Period, Capital Gains Tax Rate, and IRA Withdrawal Tax Rate. Select Traditional IRA or Roth IRA under IRA Account Type.

  3. 3

    Compare the after-tax results

    Review each account's net value, effective tax rate, and year-by-year growth. The comparison estimates taxes using the rates you enter; it does not model account eligibility or contribution limits.

Example Calculation

An investor contributes $10,000 initially and $2,000 at the end of each year for 20 years, earning 5% annually. They compare a taxable account taxed at 15% on gains with a Traditional IRA taxed at 20% on withdrawal.

Initial Investment Amount ($)

10,000

Annual Contribution ($)

2,000

Annual Growth Rate (%)

5

Investment Period (years)

20

Capital Gains Tax Rate (%)

15

IRA Withdrawal Tax Rate (%)

20

IRA Account Type

Traditional IRA (tax-deferred)

Results

Recommended Account ($)

Taxable account — $12,133.24 advantage

Taxable Net (After Tax) ($)

$86,265.15

IRA Advantage ($)

$12,133.24

Taxable Effective Tax Rate (%)

6.91%

IRA Effective Tax Rate (%)

20.00%

Total Contributions ($)

$50,000.00

Pre-Tax Growth ($)

$42,664.89

Insights card shows the account-value comparison over time.

Tips

A Roth IRA changes the comparison because qualified withdrawals are tax-free

Keep the example assumptions and select Roth IRA. The model then compares the taxable account's $86,265.15 net value with the Roth's $92,664.89, a $6,399.73 Roth advantage.

A lower withdrawal tax rate can reverse the Traditional IRA result

Change IRA Withdrawal Tax Rate from 20% to 10%. The Traditional IRA's modeled net value rises from $74,131.91 to $83,398.40; compare it with the taxable account before choosing an account.

Test a higher capital-gains rate

Raise Capital Gains Tax Rate from 15% to 20%. The taxable account's after-tax value falls because the model taxes its investment gains at withdrawal.

What this calculator estimates

This calculator compares the estimated after-tax value of investing the same money in a taxable account and an IRA. It models tax on taxable-account gains at withdrawal, tax on the full Traditional IRA withdrawal, or no tax on qualified Roth withdrawals. It does not model annual taxes on dividends or interest, fees, investment risk, or IRA eligibility rules.

How the calculation works

The model assumes annual compounding and contributions at the end of each year.

Gross future value = Initial investment × (1 + r)^n
                   + Annual contribution × [((1 + r)^n − 1) / r]

Taxable net = Gross future value − (Gross future value − Contributions) × capital-gains tax rate
Traditional IRA net = Gross future value × (1 − withdrawal tax rate)
Roth IRA net = Gross future value

Here, r is the annual growth rate as a decimal, n is the number of years, and total contributions equal the initial investment plus annual contributions multiplied by n.

For the example, the growth factor is 1.05^20 = 2.6532977. The initial investment grows to $10,000 × 2.6532977 = $26,532.98. The annual deposits grow to $2,000 × ((2.6532977 − 1) / 0.05) = $66,131.91. Together, they produce $92,664.89 before tax.

Total contributions are $10,000 + ($2,000 × 20) = $50,000, so pre-tax growth is $92,664.89 − $50,000 = $42,664.89. Tax on taxable gains is $42,664.89 × 15% = $6,399.73, leaving $86,265.15. The Traditional IRA tax is $92,664.89 × 20% = $18,532.98, leaving $74,131.91.

How account type and tax rates change the result

With the same investment assumptions, changing the IRA type changes how the model treats taxes. The table compares a taxable account with both IRA types; the Roth result assumes withdrawals qualify for tax-free treatment.

Account Tax assumption Estimated net value
Taxable 15% tax on investment gains at withdrawal $86,265.15
Traditional IRA 20% tax on the full balance at withdrawal $74,131.91
Roth IRA No tax on qualified withdrawals $92,664.89

The Traditional IRA comparison is sensitive to your future withdrawal tax rate because that rate applies to contributions as well as growth in this model. The taxable-account estimate is sensitive to the capital-gains rate, but the model omits taxes on dividends and interest along the way. Use the taxable vs. tax-deferred investment calculator to focus on the tax-deferred comparison, or the IRA growth calculator to estimate IRA accumulation.

What to check before choosing an account

A higher modeled balance is not the only factor in an account decision. Check whether you need access before retirement, whether you qualify to contribute or deduct contributions, and whether an employer plan offers matching contributions. The SEC's guide to investment accounts explains account and investment basics; FINRA also outlines IRA contribution and distribution considerations.

For a separate view of how regular deposits compound, use the ordinary annuity calculator. To model growth in a general brokerage account, use the investment account growth calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a taxable brokerage account and an IRA?

A taxable brokerage account has no IRA contribution or withdrawal rules, but investment income and realized gains can be taxable. A Traditional IRA generally defers tax until withdrawal, while qualified Roth IRA withdrawals are tax-free; account rules and eligibility requirements still apply.

How does this calculator estimate the taxable account's after-tax value?

It subtracts tax on the account's investment gains from the gross value at the end of the investment period. The simplified model does not separately tax dividends, interest, or gains realized during the investment period.

Can I contribute the same amount to an IRA every year?

Not necessarily; IRA contributions are subject to annual limits and eligibility rules. Check the IRS IRA contribution limits and rules before using the calculator's contribution as a real-world plan.

Are Traditional IRA withdrawals always taxed at the same rate?

No, the tax rate depends on your taxable income and circumstances when you withdraw. The calculator applies one assumed rate to the entire Traditional IRA balance, so it does not model tax brackets, deductions, or state taxes.

Does a Roth IRA always beat a taxable account?

No; the result depends on tax rates, investment income, account rules, and whether you qualify for tax-free Roth withdrawals. A taxable account can be more useful when you need flexible access to funds or have a low capital-gains tax rate.