Build your retirement plan for free.Explore Plan Builder →

IRA Rollover Tax Impact Calculator

Enter your rollover amount, current tax rate, and expected growth rate to calculate your immediate tax bill, long-term Roth advantage, and the break-even point versus keeping a traditional IRA.
Luis GonzalezCreated by Luis GonzalezLast updated:

How to Use This Calculator

  1. 1

    Enter the amount being converted

    Type the pre-tax amount in Rollover Amount ($). This calculator treats the full amount as taxable income for its estimate.

  2. 2

    Set the tax and investment assumptions

    Enter Current Tax Rate (%), Expected Roth Growth Rate (%), and Projection Period (yrs). Use your marginal rate as an estimate, not as a guaranteed rate on every dollar.

  3. 3

    Review the tax estimate and projected comparison

    Compare Tax Due on Rollover with the projected Roth and traditional after-tax values. The estimate does not model tax brackets, state tax, or the source of funds used to pay the tax.

Example Calculation

An investor estimates converting $30,000 from a traditional IRA at a 22% marginal tax rate and projects 6% annual growth for 20 years.

Rollover Amount ($)

30,000

Current Tax Rate (%)

22

Expected Roth Growth Rate (%)

6

Projection Period (yrs)

20

Results

Tax Due on Rollover

$6,600

Roth Value in 20 years

$96,214

Traditional IRA (After-Tax)

$75,047

Roth Tax-Free Advantage

$21,167

Effective Tax Burden

22.00%

Estimated Break-Even

0 years

Insights card shows projected Roth and traditional values and the estimated tax cost.

Tips

Compare a 12% tax rate with the 22% assumption

Change Current Tax Rate (%) to 12 and review Tax Due on Rollover. A lower marginal rate reduces the estimated immediate tax, but the actual amount depends on your taxable income and filing status.

Test a 4% growth assumption

Change Expected Roth Growth Rate (%) from 6 to 4. This lowers projected growth in both account comparisons and shows how sensitive the long-term difference is to returns.

Shorten the projection to 10 years

Change Projection Period (yrs) from 20 to 10. The conversion tax is still estimated now, while the balances have fewer years to compound.

What this calculator estimates

A Roth conversion tax calculator estimates the immediate tax on moving traditional IRA money into a Roth IRA and compares projected future balances. The calculator uses a flat current tax rate and a single growth assumption; it does not calculate your actual tax return or establish whether a conversion is financially beneficial.

How the calculation works

The immediate tax estimate is the taxable conversion amount multiplied by the entered tax rate:

Estimated conversion tax = Rollover amount × Current tax rate
Roth future value = Rollover amount × (1 + r)^n
Traditional after-tax value = Rollover amount × (1 + r)^n × (1 − tax rate)
Roth tax-free advantage = Roth future value − Traditional after-tax value

Here, r is the annual growth rate as a decimal and n is the projection period in years. These comparison formulas assume the full conversion is taxable, use the same return for both accounts, and apply the current tax rate to the traditional balance at withdrawal.

For the example, the estimated tax is $30,000 × 0.22 = $6,600. The 20-year growth factor at 6% is 1.06^20 = 3.207135. The Roth projection is $30,000 × 3.207135 = $96,214. The traditional account's projected after-tax value is $96,214 × (1 − 0.22) = $75,047. Their difference is approximately $21,167.

The break-even output depends on how the calculator defines and compares the tax payment. If the model compares an entirely tax-free Roth balance with a traditional balance reduced by tax, without subtracting the opportunity cost of paying conversion tax, it can show an immediate advantage. Paying $6,600 from outside the IRA has a real cost: those dollars are no longer available for other uses or investment.

What can change the actual tax bill

A conversion can push some income into a higher tax bracket, so applying one marginal rate to every converted dollar is only a shortcut. The taxable amount can also depend on nondeductible IRA basis and the pro-rata rules. The IRS Form 8606 instructions explain how to report basis and certain conversions.

Compare multiple conversion amounts and tax years. Converting part of an IRA in more than one year can spread taxable income across years, but the best amount depends on other income, deductions, and the tax rates you expect later. Include state income tax and any income-linked effects that this calculator omits.

Assumed tax rate Estimated tax on $30,000
12% $3,600
22% $6,600
24% $7,200

These are flat-rate estimates, not tax-bracket calculations. A conversion is generally most useful to evaluate when you compare the current tax cost with the likely future tax treatment, the time the funds can remain invested, and where the tax payment will come from.

When to use a different calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

Is converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA taxable?

A conversion of pre-tax traditional IRA money to a Roth IRA generally adds the converted amount to taxable income for that year. The IRS Roth IRA guidance explains Roth IRA tax rules; the calculator's flat-rate estimate does not replace a tax return calculation.

How do I estimate the tax on a Roth conversion?

1. Estimate how much of the conversion is taxable. 2. Estimate the additional federal and state income tax caused by that amount. 3. Compare the tax cost with the projected benefits under different future tax-rate assumptions. The calculator uses Rollover Amount × Current Tax Rate as a simplified federal estimate.

Does the calculator account for after-tax IRA basis?

No, it treats the full rollover amount as taxable and does not apply the pro-rata rules to nondeductible IRA contributions. If you have after-tax basis, review IRS Form 8606 and its instructions before estimating a conversion.

What does the break-even year mean?

A break-even year is the point at which the projected Roth advantage offsets the conversion's upfront cost under the assumptions used. A result of 0 years can arise when the comparison counts the Roth balance as tax-free but does not subtract the tax payment's opportunity cost; it is not proof that converting immediately improves total wealth.

Should I pay conversion tax from the IRA or from other savings?

Paying the tax from outside funds leaves more of the converted balance invested in the Roth, while using IRA funds reduces the amount that can compound tax-free. Compare the tax payment with your emergency reserves, other near-term cash needs, and the investment return you give up.

Will a Roth conversion affect other taxes or benefits?

It can, because the added taxable income may affect tax brackets and income-based calculations in the conversion year. The estimate does not include state tax, deductions, credits, or other income-linked costs, so model the conversion with the full tax-year picture.