Traditional vs. Roth IRA Calculator
How to Use This Calculator
- 1
Enter your Annual Contribution
Enter the amount you plan to contribute each year. Check the IRS limit for the tax year and your age before contributing.
- 2
Set both tax rates
Enter your current marginal tax rate and your estimated marginal rate in retirement. The comparison depends heavily on how these rates differ.
- 3
Set return and contribution years
Enter your expected Annual Return on Investment and Years to Contribute. Review the after-tax account values and break-even retirement tax rate as estimates, not guarantees.
Example Calculation
A saver contributes $6,500 per year for 30 years, expects a 7% annual return, pays a 24% current marginal tax rate, and expects a 22% marginal rate in retirement.
Annual Contribution ($)
6,500
Current Tax Rate (%)
24
Expected Tax Rate in Retirement (%)
22
Annual Return on Investment (%)
7
Years to Contribute (years)
30
Results
Traditional After-Tax Value
$478,916
Roth IRA Value
$466,636
Break-Even Retirement Tax Rate
24%
Annual Tax Savings (Traditional)
$1,560
Tax Outlook
22%
Insights card shows the account comparison and projected growth over time.
Tips
A higher retirement tax rate can change the winner
Raise Expected Tax Rate in Retirement above Current Tax Rate and compare the after-tax values. A Roth account becomes more attractive when the tax rate on future withdrawals is higher.
Shorter contribution periods reduce the compounding runway
Change Years to Contribute from 30 to 20 to see how much less time contributions have to grow. Keep the return and tax inputs fixed to isolate the effect of time.
Test lower returns instead of relying on one forecast
Reduce Annual Return on Investment by one or two percentage points and compare both account values. The calculator's projection is sensitive to the return assumption and does not guarantee investment performance.
What this calculator compares
A Traditional IRA generally defers income tax on deductible contributions until withdrawal, while a Roth IRA uses after-tax contributions and can provide tax-free qualified withdrawals. This calculator projects the after-tax value of each account using your contribution, tax rates, return assumption, and contribution period; it does not predict actual investment returns or determine eligibility.
How the comparison works
For equal annual contributions made at the end of each year, the future value of the contributions is:
FV = C × [((1 + r)^n − 1) / r]
Traditional after-tax value = FV × (1 − t_retirement)
Roth value = FV × (1 − t_current)
C is the annual contribution, r is the annual return as a decimal, n is the number of contribution years, and t is the relevant marginal tax rate. The break-even retirement tax rate is the current tax rate under this simplified equal-after-tax-budget comparison.
For the example, the 30-year growth factor at 7% is [(1.07^30 − 1) ÷ 0.07], or about 94.4608. The projected pre-tax value is $6,500 × 94.4608, or about $613,995. Applying the 22% retirement rate gives $613,995 × 0.78, or about $478,916 for the Traditional IRA. Applying the 24% current rate to the Roth comparison gives $613,995 × 0.76, or about $466,636.
The estimated difference is about $12,280 in favor of the Traditional IRA under these inputs. This result assumes the Traditional IRA's tax savings are accounted for through an equal-after-tax comparison; it does not project a separate account invested with those savings.
How tax rates affect the decision
The central tradeoff is when you pay tax. If your marginal rate is lower today than in retirement, paying tax now through a Roth can be favorable. If your current rate is higher than your expected retirement rate, a deductible Traditional contribution can be favorable, assuming you qualify for the deduction.
| Current tax rate | Retirement tax rate | Simplified tax-rate signal |
|---|---|---|
| 24% | 12% | Favors Traditional tax deferral |
| 24% | 24% | Tax rates are at break-even |
| 22% | 32% | Favors Roth tax treatment |
The table isolates tax rates; it does not account for contribution eligibility, deduction limits, state taxes, or future law changes. Run multiple return assumptions as well, because higher or lower investment growth changes the dollar value of the tax difference even when the break-even rate stays the same.
Check eligibility and account rules before contributing
Traditional IRA deductions can be limited when you or your spouse have a workplace retirement plan, depending on income and filing status. Roth IRA contributions can also be limited by income. The IRS updates contribution limits and eligibility thresholds, so use the rules for the specific tax year rather than carrying an old limit forward.
A decision also depends on liquidity and account access. Qualified Roth distributions and Traditional IRA withdrawals follow different tax rules, and early distributions can trigger tax or penalties depending on the circumstances. For the exact requirements, review the IRS guidance on IRA distributions.
When to use a different calculator
- You are deciding whether to convert pre-tax savings to Roth → Roth IRA Conversion Calculator
- You want to compare a backdoor Roth strategy → Backdoor Roth IRA Calculator
- You want to project IRA growth without comparing tax types → IRA Growth Calculator
- You are choosing between an IRA and an employer plan → IRA vs. 401(k) Calculator
- You need to estimate withdrawals from an IRA → IRA Distribution Calculator
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a Traditional IRA and a Roth IRA?
Traditional IRA contributions may qualify for a tax deduction, and withdrawals are generally taxable; Roth IRA contributions are made with after-tax money, and qualified withdrawals are generally tax-free. Eligibility and tax treatment depend on income, workplace plan coverage, account rules, and withdrawal circumstances. The IRS explains IRA contribution limits and account rules.
What retirement tax rate makes a Roth IRA better?
A Roth tends to gain an advantage when your tax rate on qualified retirement withdrawals is higher than the rate paid on the money contributed today. The break-even rate is a simplified comparison; deductions, contribution limits, and how you use any Traditional IRA tax savings can change the result.
Are Traditional IRA contributions always tax-deductible?
No, deductibility can be limited by income and whether you or your spouse are covered by a workplace retirement plan. Check the IRS rules for deducting IRA contributions for your filing status and tax year.
Are Roth IRA withdrawals always tax-free?
No, tax-free treatment generally applies to qualified distributions, and separate rules govern earnings, conversions, and early withdrawals. Review the IRS requirements before taking money out; this calculator estimates account values and does not determine whether a withdrawal qualifies.
What if I invest the Traditional IRA tax savings?
The comparison changes if you invest the tax savings from a deductible Traditional IRA contribution instead of spending them. This calculator compares projected IRA values and does not model a separate taxable or retirement investment account for those savings.
What is the IRA contribution limit?
The annual limit depends on the tax year and age, and contributions to Traditional and Roth IRAs share one combined limit. Check the current IRS IRA contribution limits before contributing; the limit stated for an earlier year may no longer apply.
