Mortgage Loan Comparison Calculator
How to Use This Calculator
- 1
Enter the loan amount
Use the same Loan Amount ($) for both offers so the comparison isolates the differences in rate and term.
- 2
Enter each offer's rate and term
Fill in Annual Interest Rate — Loan A (%) and Loan B (%), then Loan Term — Loan A (years) and Loan B (years). Set Payments Per Year to match your payment schedule; monthly payments use 12.
- 3
Compare payments and lifetime costs
Review each loan's monthly payment, total interest, and total cost. A lower total cost can come with a higher monthly payment if that loan has a shorter term.
Example Calculation
A borrower compares a $200,000 mortgage at 4% for 30 years with one at 3.5% for 15 years, making monthly payments.
Loan Amount ($)
200,000
Annual Interest Rate — Loan A (%)
4
Annual Interest Rate — Loan B (%)
3.5
Loan Term — Loan A (years)
30
Loan Term — Loan B (years)
15
Payments Per Year
12
Results
Best Overall Value
Loan B
Monthly Payment A
$954.83
Monthly Payment B
$1,429.49
Total Interest A
$143,739.01
Total Interest B
$57,307.00
Total Cost A
$343,739.01
Total Cost B
$257,307.00
Interest Savings
$86,432.01
Tips
Loan B costs about $474.66 more per month in this comparison
Change Loan Term — Loan B (years) from 15 to 30 to see how extending the term lowers its monthly payment and increases the interest paid.
The lower rate is not the only difference to test
Keep both terms at 30 years, then change Annual Interest Rate — Loan B (%) to 3.5. This isolates the rate effect instead of comparing a lower rate and shorter term at once.
A payment schedule changes the comparison
Change Payments Per Year from 12 to 26 to model biweekly payments, then check whether both offers use the same schedule before comparing their totals.
What this calculator compares
A mortgage loan comparison estimates principal-and-interest payments and total borrowing costs for two loans with the same loan amount. It does not include taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, lender fees, or discount points, so treat the result as a loan-cost comparison rather than a complete housing budget.
How the comparison is calculated
The calculator uses the fixed-payment amortization formula for each loan:
M = P × r / (1 − (1 + r)^(-n))
Here, M is the payment per period, P is the loan amount, r is the interest rate per payment period, and n is the total number of payments. For monthly payments, divide the annual rate by 12 and multiply the loan term in years by 12. Total interest is M × n − P; total cost is M × n.
For Loan A in the example, P = $200,000, r = 0.04 / 12, and n = 30 × 12 = 360. The monthly payment is about $954.83; multiplying by 360 gives $343,739.01 in total payments, including $143,739.01 of interest. For Loan B, r = 0.035 / 12 and n = 15 × 12 = 180. Its payment is about $1,429.49; total payments are $257,307.00, including $57,307.00 of interest.
Loan B therefore saves about $86,432.01 in interest over its full term, but requires a substantially larger monthly payment. The mortgage calculator can add taxes, insurance, and other housing costs to the payment estimate.
How rate and term change the result
A lower rate reduces borrowing cost when the other inputs stay the same. A shorter term also reduces total interest, but it concentrates repayment into fewer, larger payments.
| Loan amount | Annual rate | Term | Approx. monthly payment | Approx. total interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $200,000 | 4.0% | 30 years | $954.83 | $143,739 |
| $200,000 | 4.0% | 15 years | $1,479.38 | $66,288 |
| $200,000 | 3.5% | 30 years | $898.09 | $123,312 |
Use a same-term comparison to isolate rate differences, then compare terms at a rate each lender actually offers. If one offer requires points or has higher fees, compare those separately with the mortgage points calculator. For a broader comparison that can include loan fees and other terms, use the home loan comparison calculator.
Decide based on both payment and holding period
The lowest lifetime cost is useful only if the required payment fits your cash flow. A 15-year term can save interest, but the higher payment leaves less money available for emergency savings, retirement contributions, or other debt payments.
If you expect to sell or refinance before the loan ends, compare the balance and cumulative payments at that date. Ask lenders for the Loan Estimate and amortization schedule, and check whether rates are fixed or adjustable. For an adjustable-rate offer, model future rate changes with an adjustable-rate mortgage calculator.
When to use a different calculator
- Estimate a full monthly housing payment with taxes and insurance → mortgage calculator
- Compare points and the rate reduction they buy → mortgage points calculator
- Model rate changes after an adjustable-rate period → adjustable-rate mortgage calculator
- Compare a mortgage with other borrowing options → loan calculator
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I compare two mortgage loans?
Compare the monthly payment, total interest, total cost, and the time you expect to keep the loan. 1. Enter the same principal for both loans. 2. Enter each offer’s interest rate and term. 3. Compare the payment against your budget and the total cost over the loan term.
Does the lowest interest rate always mean the cheapest mortgage?
No, because loan term, fees, and how long you keep the loan also affect the cost. This calculator compares principal-and-interest payments and does not include lender fees, points, taxes, or insurance; use the lender’s Loan Estimate to compare those charges. The CFPB explains how to compare Loan Estimates.
Why does a shorter mortgage have a higher payment but lower total interest?
A shorter term repays the principal faster, so each payment is larger and fewer payments accrue interest. Check whether the higher payment leaves enough room in your budget for savings and unexpected expenses before choosing the shorter term.
What costs are not included in this comparison?
The calculation covers principal and interest, not the full cost of homeownership. Property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, HOA dues, closing costs, and discount points can change which offer is less expensive.
What if I plan to sell before the mortgage is paid off?
Compare the loan balances and total payments at the year you expect to sell, rather than relying only on lifetime interest. Ask each lender for an amortization schedule and check whether the loan has a prepayment penalty or other charges.
