Build your retirement plan for free.Explore Plan Builder →

Long-Term vs Short-Term Rental Comparison Calculator

Enter your rental rates, occupancy, and expenses to compare long-term lease income against short-term rental (Airbnb/VRBO) net income with multi-year projections.
Luis GonzalezCreated by Luis GonzalezLast updated:

How to Use This Calculator

  1. 1

    Enter the long-term rental income and costs

    Set Long-Term Monthly Rent and Long-Term Annual Expenses. Include recurring costs such as maintenance, insurance, and management.

  2. 2

    Enter short-term rental assumptions

    Set Short-Term Nightly Rate, Short-Term Occupancy Rate, and Short-Term Annual Costs. Occupancy is the share of 365 nights booked.

  3. 3

    Choose a Projection Period

    Select the number of years, up to 20, to compare projected cumulative net income. The projection does not account for rent growth, appreciation, or changing costs.

Example Calculation

A property earns $2,000 per month under a long-term lease. A short-term rental charges $150 per night, is booked 65% of the year, and has $8,000 in annual costs. Compare both strategies over five years.

Long-Term Monthly Rent ($)

2,000

Long-Term Annual Expenses ($)

3,000

Short-Term Nightly Rate ($)

150

Short-Term Occupancy Rate (%)

65

Short-Term Annual Costs ($)

8,000

Projection Period (yrs)

5

Results

Recommended Strategy

Short-Term Rental

Long-Term Annual Net

$21,000

Short-Term Annual Net

$27,587.50

Annual Income Difference

$6,587.50

Short-Term Gross Revenue

$35,587.50

Insights card shows the income and margin comparison.

Tips

The short-term option assumes 237.25 booked nights per year

Change Short-Term Occupancy Rate from 65% to 50% to test a slower booking year. Gross short-term revenue falls from $35,587.50 to $27,375 before annual costs.

Annual costs can reverse the strategy comparison

Increase Short-Term Annual Costs from $8,000 to $15,000 to see how cleaning, utilities, platform fees, and management change the short-term net.

A five-year projection holds every input constant

Set Projection Period (yrs) to 10 to compare a longer flat-income projection. The calculator does not add rent increases, inflation, or home-price appreciation.

What this calculator compares

This calculator compares estimated annual net income from a long-term lease with a short-term rental, then projects those amounts across a selected number of years. It subtracts the annual operating costs you enter, but does not include financing, taxes, major renovations, or changes in rent, rates, or occupancy.

How the rental comparison is calculated

Long-term gross rent = monthly rent × 12
Long-term annual net = long-term gross rent − long-term annual expenses

Short-term booked nights = 365 × occupancy rate
Short-term gross revenue = nightly rate × booked nights
Short-term annual net = short-term gross revenue − short-term annual costs

Income difference = short-term annual net − long-term annual net
Projected net income = annual net income × projection period

Occupancy rate is converted to a decimal before multiplication. For the example, long-term gross rent is $2,000 × 12 = $24,000, and long-term annual net is $24,000 − $3,000 = $21,000.

The short-term estimate uses 365 × 0.65 = 237.25 booked nights. Gross revenue is $150 × 237.25 = $35,587.50; subtracting $8,000 in costs gives $27,587.50 in annual net income. The difference is $27,587.50 − $21,000 = $6,587.50 per year.

How occupancy and costs change the comparison

The short-term strategy has higher modeled net income only while its extra revenue exceeds its additional costs. The table holds the nightly rate and annual costs at the example inputs and varies occupancy.

Short-term occupancy Booked nights Gross revenue Net after $8,000 costs
50% 182.5 $27,375 $19,375
65% 237.25 $35,587.50 $27,587.50
80% 292 $43,800 $35,800

At 50% occupancy, modeled short-term net is below the long-term net. Test realistic low-season occupancy and include turnover costs before treating a higher nightly rate as higher profit.

Costs and assumptions to check before choosing

A long-term lease generally involves fewer turnovers, while short-term hosting can require more cleaning, furnishing, guest communication, and active management. The calculator counts those costs only when you enter them. It also treats income and costs as flat each year, so its projection is a comparison of repeated annual estimates rather than a full property investment forecast.

For a broader income-and-expense estimate, use the rental income calculator. To compare rent with property value, use the rental yield calculator. To estimate taxes on rental income, use the rental income tax calculator.

When to use a different calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

How does the calculator estimate short-term rental income?

It multiplies the nightly rate by 365 nights and the occupancy rate, then subtracts annual short-term costs. This estimates operating net income, not cash flow after a mortgage, income taxes, or capital improvements.

Does the short-term rental result include cleaning fees?

Only if you include them in Short-Term Annual Costs. Add cleaning, supplies, platform fees, utilities, management, and other operating costs to avoid overstating net income.

Does this comparison include local rental rules and taxes?

No, it compares income and expenses entered in the calculator. Check local zoning, licensing, lodging-tax, and homeowners-association rules before choosing a short-term strategy; the CFPB homebuying guide also covers costs to account for when evaluating a property.

Is the recommended strategy a guarantee of higher profit?

No, it is the strategy with the higher modeled annual net using your inputs. Actual bookings, vacancies, repairs, regulation, and management time can change the result.

How is rental income taxed?

Tax treatment depends on the property and how you operate it; this calculator does not estimate taxes. The IRS explains rental income, expenses, and recordkeeping in Publication 527.