Build your retirement plan for free.Explore Plan Builder →

Home Equity vs. Personal Loan Calculator

Enter a loan amount with rates and terms for both a home equity loan and a personal loan to see side-by-side monthly payments, total interest, and which option costs less overall. Includes a balance paydown comparison chart.
Luis GonzalezCreated by Luis GonzalezLast updated:

How to Use This Calculator

  1. 1

    Enter the shared Loan Amount

    Use the amount you need to borrow so both options are compared on the same principal.

  2. 2

    Enter each loan's rate and term

    Set the home equity loan's Interest Rate and Loan Term, then enter the personal loan's Interest Rate and Loan Term. Each option can have a different payoff period.

  3. 3

    Compare payments, interest, and balances

    Review the total-cost winner, monthly payments, interest totals, payment difference, and year-by-year balance chart. The lower total interest option can still have a higher monthly payment.

Example Calculation

A borrower compares a $50,000 home equity loan at 8% for 15 years with a $50,000 personal loan at 12% for 5 years.

Loan Amount ($)

50,000

Home Equity Loan Interest Rate (%)

8

Home Equity Loan Term (years)

15

Personal Loan Interest Rate (%)

12

Personal Loan Term (years)

5

Results

Best Option by Total Cost

Personal Loan

Home Equity Monthly Payment

$477.83

Personal Loan Monthly Payment

$1,112.22

Home Equity Total Interest

$36,008.69

Personal Loan Total Interest

$16,733.35

Monthly Payment Difference

$634.40

Insights card shows each loan's annual balance and interest comparison.

Tips

The 5-year personal loan costs less interest but requires a much larger payment

Change the Personal Loan Term from 5 years to 10 years and compare its monthly payment and total interest. A longer term lowers the scheduled payment but increases the time interest accrues.

A smaller rate gap can change which option costs less

Change the Home Equity Interest Rate from 8% to 10% while keeping the terms fixed. Compare total interest again; the calculator selects its winner using total interest, not risk or fees.

Test the same payoff term to isolate the rate difference

Set both Loan Term fields to 5 years. The payment and total-interest comparison then reflects the rates on the same principal over the same repayment period.

What this calculator estimates

This calculator compares two fixed-rate borrowing options for the same principal: a home equity loan secured by your home and an unsecured personal loan. It calculates each monthly payment and total interest, then names the option with lower modeled interest as the best option by total cost.

The result is not a complete loan-offer comparison. It excludes origination fees, home equity closing costs, taxes, rate discounts, prepayment penalties, and collateral risk. The winner label is based on interest alone.

How the calculation works

Monthly payment = principal × monthly rate × (1 + monthly rate)^n
                  ÷ ((1 + monthly rate)^n − 1)
Total interest = monthly payment × number of payments − principal
Interest difference = absolute value of the two total-interest amounts

For the example, the home equity loan has a monthly rate of 8% ÷ 12 and 15 × 12 = 180 payments. Its payment is $477.83, and its modeled total interest is $36,008.69. The personal loan has a monthly rate of 12% ÷ 12 and 5 × 12 = 60 payments. Its payment is $1,112.22, and its modeled total interest is $16,733.35.

The personal loan's interest total is lower by $36,008.69 − $16,733.35 = $19,275.34. Its higher payment reflects the much shorter payoff period. In this comparison, the home equity payment is lower by $1,112.22 − $477.83 = $634.40 per month, but the home equity loan runs for ten years longer.

Term length changes the comparison

The table holds the $50,000 principal and both rates at their example values, then changes the personal loan term. The home equity loan remains at 8% for 15 years.

Personal loan term at 12% Personal loan monthly payment Personal loan total interest Difference from home equity interest
3 years $1,660.72 $9,785.83 $26,222.86 less
5 years $1,112.22 $16,733.35 $19,275.34 less
10 years $717.35 $36,081.51 $72.82 more

A lower payment does not necessarily mean a lower total cost. Compare offers at similar terms when you want to isolate the rate effect; compare the actual terms when monthly affordability is the main constraint. The schedule chart helps show how quickly each balance falls.

Compare collateral, fees, and flexibility

A personal loan is unsecured, so it does not directly pledge your home; it can carry a higher rate or origination fee. A home equity loan may offer a lower rate, but your home secures the debt, and closing costs can reduce or erase the interest savings. Get written quotes and compare APR, total fees, monthly payment, prepayment rules, and the consequences of missing payments.

If the home equity offer uses a variable-rate line rather than a fixed lump-sum loan, compare it with the HELOC calculator. For a detailed fixed home equity loan estimate, use the Home Equity Loan Calculator. You can also model the unsecured offer with the Personal Loan Calculator.

When to use a different calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, a home equity loan or a personal loan?

The cheaper option depends on the interest rate, fees, and repayment term, not only whether the loan is secured. This calculator compares modeled interest for the terms entered, but it does not include origination fees, closing costs, or the risk of pledging your home.

Why can the loan with less total interest have a higher monthly payment?

A shorter repayment term packs principal repayment into fewer months, which can raise the monthly payment even when total interest is lower. Compare monthly affordability as well as lifetime cost before choosing.

What is the risk of using home equity to consolidate debt?

A home equity loan turns unsecured borrowing into debt secured by your home, so missed payments can put the property at risk. The CFPB explains home-secured borrowing risks in its consumer guidance on home equity loans and lines of credit.

Does this comparison include fees or tax deductions?

No, it compares principal-and-interest payments and excludes loan fees, closing costs, and taxes. Home equity interest is not automatically deductible; the IRS explains qualifying use and limits in Publication 936.

Should I use a home equity loan or personal loan for an emergency?

A personal loan does not put your home up as collateral, while a home equity loan may offer a lower rate but adds property risk and potentially closing costs. Compare the actual APR, fees, funding time, payment, and consequences of missing a payment; use the [Personal Loan Calculator](/calculators/personal-loan-calculator/) to examine the unsecured option separately.