Auto Loan vs Home Equity Loan Calculator
How to Use This Calculator
- 1
Enter the vehicle cost and upfront contribution
Fill in Vehicle Price ($), Down Payment ($), and Trade-In Value ($). The calculator uses the resulting amount as the principal for both loan types.
- 2
Enter the auto and home equity loan terms
Enter each rate, term, and fee, plus Home Value ($) and Existing Mortgage Balance ($). Add Marginal Tax Rate (%) only to inspect the calculator’s hypothetical tax estimate.
- 3
Compare total cost and check equity eligibility
Review both payments, total costs, and Home Equity Available ($). The displayed tax savings are not a tax determination; interest used to buy a personal vehicle generally does not qualify as home mortgage interest.
Example Calculation
A buyer finances a $35,000 vehicle with $7,000 down. The auto offer is 6.5% for 60 months with $500 in fees; the home equity offer is 5.2% for 120 months with $2,000 in fees. The home is worth $300,000 with a $200,000 mortgage.
Vehicle Price ($)
35,000
Down Payment ($)
7,000
Trade-In Value ($)
0
Auto Loan Rate (%)
6.5
Auto Loan Term (months)
60
Auto Loan Fees ($)
500
Home Value ($)
300,000
Existing Mortgage Balance ($)
200,000
Home Equity Rate (%)
5.2
Home Equity Term (months)
120
Home Equity Fees ($)
2,000
Marginal Tax Rate (%)
22
Results
Recommended Option
Auto Loan
Auto Loan Monthly Payment
about $547.80
Home Equity Monthly Payment
about $299.71
Auto Loan Total Cost
about $33,368
Home Equity Total Cost
about $36,213 after the calculator’s estimated tax savings
Home Equity Available
$55,000
Insights card shows the estimated cost comparison and combined loan-to-value.
Tips
The 120-month home equity term lowers the payment but extends the debt
Change Home Equity Term (months) from 120 to 60. The monthly payment rises, but the payoff period and interest accumulation shrink.
Set Marginal Tax Rate (%) to 0 to remove the modeled tax benefit
For a loan used to buy a personal vehicle, do not assume the home equity interest is deductible. Set the rate to 0 to compare costs without the calculator’s hypothetical tax savings.
A $2,000 fee needs to be recovered through lower borrowing costs
Change Home Equity Fees ($) to $0 and compare total cost. This isolates the impact of closing costs from the rate and term.
What this calculator compares
An auto loan versus a home equity loan comparison estimates the cost of financing a vehicle with either a vehicle-secured loan or debt secured by your home. It compares payments, interest, fees, and an equity estimate, but its tax-savings figure is only a mathematical scenario and does not establish that interest is deductible.
How the loan costs are calculated
Amount borrowed = Vehicle price − Down payment − Trade-in value
Monthly payment = P × r / (1 − (1 + r)^−n)
Total interest = (Monthly payment × n) − P
Total cost = Total payments + fees
Estimated home equity tax savings = Home equity interest × Marginal tax rate
Home equity available = max(0, 85% × Home value − Existing mortgage balance)
P is the amount borrowed, r is the annual rate divided by 12, and n is the term in months. For the example, the amount borrowed is $35,000 − $7,000 − $0 = $28,000. At 6.5% for 60 months, the auto payment is about $547.80; total payments are about $547.80 × 60 = $32,868, and adding $500 in fees gives an estimated total cost of $33,368.
For the home equity loan, the calculator uses $28,000 at 5.2% over 120 months, producing an estimated payment of about $299.71 and roughly $7,965 in interest. Its displayed tax estimate applies 22% to that interest, or about $1,752, then subtracts that amount from the home equity cost. That is not a valid tax conclusion for vehicle financing: the IRS rules for home mortgage interest generally require the proceeds to be used to buy, build, or substantially improve the home securing the debt.
Compare payment, term, and collateral risk
The lower monthly payment is not necessarily the lower-cost choice. In this example, the home equity option spreads repayment over ten years, while the auto loan ends after five years. A home equity loan also puts the home at risk if you cannot repay; an auto loan typically puts the vehicle at risk.
| Financing choice | Term | Approx. monthly payment | Approx. total cost in calculator | Main tradeoff |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Auto loan | 60 months | $547.80 | $33,368 | Higher payment; vehicle secures the debt |
| Home equity loan | 120 months | $299.71 | $36,213 after modeled tax savings | Lower payment; longer debt secured by the home |
The home equity total in this comparison includes the calculator’s hypothetical tax reduction. Because vehicle purchase interest generally does not qualify for the home mortgage interest deduction, compare without that reduction unless a tax professional confirms your specific facts. The CFPB’s home equity guidance describes the borrowing and repayment risks.
For a more appropriate baseline, set Marginal Tax Rate (%) to 0 and compare the loan payments, fees, and total interest. Review the home equity loan calculator and auto loan calculator separately to inspect each financing structure. The auto loan affordability calculator can help test whether the shorter-term payment fits your budget.
Equity eligibility is only an estimate
The calculator estimates available equity using an 85% combined loan-to-value assumption: 85% × $300,000 − $200,000 = $55,000. The $28,000 vehicle loan amount falls below that estimate, but an actual lender may use a different limit, appraisal, credit review, or income test. Confirm eligibility and closing costs directly with the lender.
When to use a different calculator
- Model a home equity loan on its own → Home Equity Loan Calculator
- Estimate a vehicle loan payment and interest → Auto Loan Calculator
- Compare home equity borrowing with an unsecured personal loan → Home Equity vs. Personal Loan Calculator
- Compare auto loan offers with different rates and terms → Auto Loan Interest Comparison Calculator
Do not treat the modeled tax savings as a promised deduction. Tax treatment depends on how the debt proceeds are used and the applicable rules; the IRS explains the requirements in its home mortgage interest guidance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I deduct home equity loan interest used to buy a car?
Generally, no: interest on home equity debt is deductible as qualified residence interest only when the debt is used to buy, build, or substantially improve the home securing the loan, subject to applicable limits. Using the proceeds to buy a vehicle does not meet that use test. See the IRS guidance on home mortgage interest deductions; do not rely on the calculator’s hypothetical tax savings as a tax benefit.
Is a home equity loan cheaper than an auto loan?
Not automatically; compare total interest, fees, repayment term, and the risk of securing the debt with your home. A lower rate or monthly payment can still result in a higher total cost if the home equity term is much longer.
What does Home Equity Available mean in this calculator?
It estimates 85% of the home value minus the existing mortgage balance, with a floor of zero. This is a calculator assumption, not a lender approval or a universal borrowing limit; lenders set their own loan-to-value, credit, and income requirements.
What is the risk of using home equity to finance a car?
A home equity loan is secured by your home, so missed payments can put the home at risk of foreclosure. An auto loan is generally secured by the vehicle instead; compare the collateral risk as well as the interest and payment. The CFPB’s home equity guidance explains how home equity borrowing works.
Why can the home equity option have a much lower monthly payment?
The calculator allows a longer home equity term, which spreads repayment over more months. That lowers each payment but can increase total interest and keeps the home-secured debt outstanding longer.
