IRA Conversion Calculator
What to do with this number
Your conversion estimate shows the tax cost of moving money between IRA types. Compare with a Roth-specific conversion model, check whether distributions from the current account trigger penalties, or estimate the early withdrawal penalty if you need the funds before 59½.
How to Use This Calculator
- 1
Enter your Traditional IRA Balance
Use the balance you plan to convert, not the amount you intend to contribute in the future.
- 2
Set the Conversion Percentage and Current Tax Rate
Choose the share of the balance to convert and enter your current marginal tax rate. The calculator treats the converted amount as ordinary income.
- 3
Enter your Expected Retirement Tax Rate
Compare your current rate with the rate you expect to pay on traditional withdrawals in retirement. Results assume 7% annual growth for 20 years.
Example Calculation
An investor converts a $50,000 traditional IRA in full, pays a 22% current tax rate, and expects a 20% tax rate in retirement.
Traditional IRA Balance ($)
50,000
Conversion Percentage (%)
100
Current Tax Rate (%)
22
Expected Retirement Tax Rate (%)
20
Results
Roth Future Value
$193,484
Tax Due on Conversion
$11,000
Conversion Benefit vs. Traditional
$38,697
Traditional After-Tax Value
$154,787
Effective Conversion Cost
22.0%
Tax Rate Comparison
2.0% difference
Amount Converted
$50,000
Breakeven Period
3.7 years
Insights card shows the estimated tax-rate difference and conversion impact.
Tips
A 50% conversion reduces the modeled upfront tax to $5,500
Change Conversion Percentage from 100% to 50% to compare the $25,000 conversion and its estimated tax with converting the full balance.
A 24% current tax rate raises the estimated tax to $12,000
Change Current Tax Rate from 22% to 24% while leaving the conversion at $50,000. Compare the higher upfront tax with the modeled retirement tax.
An equal tax rate removes the modeled rate advantage
Set Expected Retirement Tax Rate to 22% to see how the estimated Roth-versus-traditional advantage changes when the two rates match.
What this calculator estimates
A Roth IRA conversion moves money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA and can create taxable income in the year of conversion. This calculator estimates the tax on the converted amount and compares simplified future values; it does not calculate your actual tax return, account basis, or the effect of tax brackets.
How the conversion comparison works
The calculator assumes 7% annual growth for 20 years. It treats the converted amount as the Roth starting balance and compares its future value with the same balance in a traditional IRA after estimated retirement tax.
Amount converted = Traditional IRA balance × Conversion percentage
Estimated conversion tax = Amount converted × Current tax rate
Roth future value = Amount converted × (1 + 0.07)^20
Traditional after-tax value =
Amount converted × (1 + 0.07)^20 × (1 − retirement tax rate)
For the example, the converted amount is $50,000 × 100% = $50,000. Estimated tax is $50,000 × 22% = $11,000. At 7% growth, the future-value factor over 20 years is about 3.8697, so the modeled Roth value is $50,000 × 3.8697 = about $193,484. Applying a 20% retirement tax to the traditional account leaves about $193,484 × 80% = $154,787. The modeled difference is about $38,697.
The comparison assumes the conversion tax is paid from money outside the IRA. It does not subtract the $11,000 tax from the Roth balance before calculating growth. If you pay the tax from the IRA, the Roth account starts with less and the comparison changes.
How the tax-rate assumptions affect the decision
The main tradeoff is paying tax now versus paying tax on traditional withdrawals later. A conversion can be more attractive when the current marginal rate is lower than the expected retirement rate, but the calculator does not determine either rate for you.
| Current rate | Expected retirement rate | Tax on a $50,000 conversion | Rate difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12% | 20% | $6,000 | Current rate is 8 points lower |
| 22% | 20% | $11,000 | Current rate is 2 points higher |
| 24% | 24% | $12,000 | Rates are equal |
A large conversion can push taxable income into a higher bracket or affect deductions, credits, and income-based premiums. Consider testing partial conversions across separate tax years rather than assuming the entire balance should be converted at once.
What to check before converting
The taxable amount can be affected by after-tax basis in traditional IRAs and the pro-rata rule. The conversion can also affect estimated tax payments and other income-related calculations. The IRS explains IRA contribution basis and conversions in Publication 590-A; use your full tax situation rather than the calculator’s flat-rate estimate.
To model future account growth with different contributions, use the IRA growth calculator. For a withdrawal plan after retirement, compare the IRA distribution calculator and the retirement withdrawal calculator. If you are comparing account types rather than conversion timing, use the IRA vs. 401(k) calculator.
When to use a different calculator
- Estimate required distributions from a traditional IRA → IRA distribution calculator
- Project IRA growth from contributions and investment returns → IRA growth calculator
- Compare workplace-plan contributions with IRA savings → 401(k) contribution calculator
- Estimate income from a retirement withdrawal plan → retirement withdrawal calculator
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Roth IRA conversion?
A Roth conversion moves eligible funds from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA and generally makes the taxable portion of the converted amount ordinary income for that year. Qualified Roth withdrawals can be tax-free, but conversion taxes and distribution rules still matter.
How is the tax on an IRA conversion estimated?
1. Multiply the amount converted by your current marginal tax rate for a rough estimate. 2. Add the conversion income to your other taxable income to check whether it crosses tax brackets or affects other tax items. 3. Account for any nondeductible basis and the pro-rata rule before estimating the actual tax. This calculator uses the first step only.
Is converting to a Roth IRA always better if my retirement tax rate will be higher?
No; a higher expected retirement tax rate favors Roth treatment in this simplified comparison, but the result depends on whether you can pay the conversion tax without using retirement funds, how long the money can grow, and future tax rules. The calculator assumes a fixed 7% return and does not model tax brackets or investment alternatives.
Can I pay the conversion tax from the IRA?
You can have tax withheld from a conversion, but the withheld amount does not reach the Roth account and can create an early-distribution tax or penalty if you are under 59½ and no exception applies. Paying the tax from non-retirement funds preserves more of the converted balance for potential tax-free growth.
What is the pro-rata rule for an IRA conversion?
The pro-rata rule generally treats traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRA funds together when calculating the taxable and nontaxable portions of a conversion. You cannot select only the after-tax dollars if pretax IRA balances also exist; review IRS Publication 590-A and your tax records before converting.
