Build your retirement plan for free.Explore Plan Builder →

Insurance Deductible Comparison Calculator

Enter your monthly premiums, deductibles, and expected claim amounts for two policies to compare total out-of-pocket costs and insurer payouts side by side.
Luis GonzalezCreated by Luis GonzalezLast updated:

How to Use This Calculator

  1. 1

    Enter Policy 1’s premium, deductible, and claim

    Use Policy 1 Monthly Premium ($), Policy 1 Deductible ($), and Policy 1 Claim Amount ($). Enter the monthly premium, the amount you pay before coverage applies, and the claim amount.

  2. 2

    Enter the same details for Policy 2

    Fill in Policy 2 Monthly Premium ($), Policy 2 Deductible ($), and Policy 2 Claim Amount ($). Use comparable claims and coverage terms for a meaningful comparison.

  3. 3

    Compare insurer payments and annual costs

    Review each insurer payout, each policy’s Total Annual Cost, and Best Overall Policy. The annual-cost result combines 12 months of premiums with the entered deductible.

Example Calculation

Two policies cover the same $15,000 claim. Policy 1 costs $150 per month with a $2,000 deductible; Policy 2 costs $120 per month with a $1,000 deductible.

Policy 1 Monthly Premium ($)

150

Policy 1 Deductible ($)

2,000

Policy 1 Claim Amount ($)

15,000

Policy 2 Monthly Premium ($)

120

Policy 2 Deductible ($)

1,000

Policy 2 Claim Amount ($)

15,000

Results

Best Overall Policy

Policy 2

Policy 1 — Insurer Pays

$13,000

Policy 2 — Insurer Pays

$14,000

Policy 1 — Total Annual Cost

$3,800

Policy 2 — Total Annual Cost

$2,440

Net Claim Advantage

$1,000

Insights card shows the lower modeled annual cost and the insurer payout difference.

Tips

Policy 2 costs $1,360 less in the modeled year

Change Policy 2 Monthly Premium ($) from 120 to 150 to test how much of its current annual-cost advantage comes from its lower premium.

A $1,000 deductible gap changes the insurer payout by $1,000 on this claim

Change Policy 2 Deductible ($) from 1,000 to 2,000 while keeping the claim at $15,000. Compare the payout and Net Claim Advantage.

Test a smaller claim before choosing a policy

Change both claim amounts from 15,000 to 1,500. A claim below a deductible can produce no insurer payment in the calculator, making premium and deductible tradeoffs easier to see.

What this calculator compares

An insurance deductible comparison estimates each insurer’s payment on a claim and compares that amount with annual premiums plus the deductible. It is a simplified one-claim scenario, not a complete policy comparison or claim settlement.

How the comparison is calculated

Insurer payment = max(0, claim amount − deductible)
Modeled annual cost = deductible + (monthly premium × 12)

The claim amount is the loss entered for that policy. The deductible is the amount applied to the claim before the insurer pays. The annual premium is the monthly premium multiplied by 12. The calculator labels the lower modeled annual cost as the better overall policy for these inputs.

For the guide example, Policy 1’s insurer payment is $15,000 − $2,000 = $13,000. Its annual premium is $150 × 12 = $1,800, so its modeled annual cost is $2,000 + $1,800 = $3,800.

Policy 2 pays $15,000 − $1,000 = $14,000. Its annual premium is $120 × 12 = $1,440, so its modeled annual cost is $1,000 + $1,440 = $2,440. Policy 2’s modeled cost is $3,800 − $2,440 = $1,360 lower, while its insurer pays $1,000 more on this claim.

How the claim size changes the comparison

The policy with the lower deductible does not always have the lower total cost. The premium difference repeats each month, while a deductible difference matters when a claim occurs. This table changes the claim amount while keeping the example premiums and deductibles fixed; modeled annual cost still adds the full deductible and annual premiums.

Claim amount Policy 1 insurer pays Policy 2 insurer pays Policy 1 modeled annual cost Policy 2 modeled annual cost
$800 $0 $0 $3,800 $2,440
$1,500 $0 $500 $3,800 $2,440
$15,000 $13,000 $14,000 $3,800 $2,440

The calculator’s annual-cost formula adds the full deductible even when the claim is smaller than that deductible. For a real claim, your payment generally depends on the covered loss and policy wording; do not use the table as a settlement estimate.

How to choose between premium and deductible

A higher deductible can reduce the premium, but it shifts more of a covered loss to you. Compare the annual premium savings with the extra deductible you would have to pay, then test more than one claim size. If a higher deductible would strain your cash reserves, the lower premium may not justify the added risk.

Before switching, compare coverage limits, exclusions, claim conditions, and any separate deductibles that apply to specific risks. A policy with a lower modeled cost may provide less coverage or apply different terms. The NAIC’s consumer resources offer guidance for reviewing insurance policies.

When to use a different calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an insurance deductible?

A deductible is the amount you pay toward a covered loss before the insurer pays under the policy. The policy’s terms determine which claims have a deductible and how it applies.

How does this calculator compare two deductibles?

It subtracts each deductible from its claim to estimate the insurer payment, then adds 12 months of premiums to the deductible for a modeled annual cost. 1. Calculate the insurer payment as the claim minus the deductible, with a minimum of zero. 2. Multiply the monthly premium by 12. 3. Add that annual premium to the deductible.

Does the lower-deductible policy always cost less?

No, a lower deductible often comes with a higher premium, and the total depends on how often you make claims and the size of covered losses. Compare both the recurring premium and the amount you would need to pay after a claim.

Does this result show my exact out-of-pocket cost?

No, it is a simplified comparison, not a full claim settlement estimate. It assumes one deductible and 12 premium payments, and does not model coinsurance, exclusions, coverage limits, multiple claims, or whether the deductible is capped at the claim amount.

What should I check in the policy before switching?

Check that the policies cover the same risks, limits, and claim types before comparing their premiums and deductibles. The NAIC’s consumer insurance resources explain insurance terms and provide guidance for reviewing coverage.

How much should I keep available for a higher deductible?

Keep enough accessible cash to pay the deductible and other likely costs of a loss before choosing a higher one. This calculator compares modeled costs but cannot determine whether you can comfortably absorb that expense.