Build your retirement plan for free.Explore Plan Builder →

Home Loan Comparison Calculator

Enter the details for two loan options to compare monthly payments, total interest, and total cost side by side. The calculator determines which loan is the better deal and shows a year-by-year balance paydown chart.
Luis GonzalezCreated by Luis GonzalezLast updated:

How to Use This Calculator

  1. 1

    Enter Loan A's amount, interest rate, and term

    Use the principal you plan to borrow, annual interest rate, and repayment term in years.

  2. 2

    Enter the same details for Loan B

    Use the second lender's or loan structure's principal, rate, and term. Compare equivalent loan amounts when you want to isolate the effect of rate and term.

  3. 3

    Compare total cost, payments, and yearly balances

    Review which loan has lower modeled total repayment, each monthly payment, the interest totals, and the balance and interest rows by year.

Example Calculation

A borrower compares $350,000 at 6.5% for 30 years with $350,000 at 5.9% for 15 years.

Loan A Loan Amount ($)

350,000

Loan A Interest Rate (%)

6.5

Loan A Term (years)

30

Loan B Loan Amount ($)

350,000

Loan B Interest Rate (%)

5.9

Loan B Term (years)

15

Results

Better Deal by Total Cost

Loan B

Loan A Monthly Payment

$2,212.24

Loan B Monthly Payment

$2,934.62

Loan A Total Interest

$446,405.75

Loan B Total Interest

$178,232.30

Monthly Payment Difference

$722.39

Insights card shows which loan has lower modeled repayment and the interest difference.

Tips

Loan B's payment is $722.39 higher each month

Test whether the 15-year payment fits your monthly budget after housing costs, savings, and other debt. A lower total cost is not useful if the required payment is unaffordable.

Loan B's shorter term reduces modeled interest by $268,173.45

Change Loan B's Interest Rate (%) or Term (years) to test how much of the difference comes from its rate versus its shorter payoff period.

The comparison excludes fees and mortgage insurance

Add lender fees, points, taxes, insurance, and any mortgage insurance from your written Loan Estimates before choosing. The [CFPB's Loan Estimate guide](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/owning-a-home/loan-estimate/) explains the costs to compare.

What this calculator compares

A home loan comparison calculator compares two fully amortizing loans using their principal amounts, annual interest rates, and repayment terms. It identifies the lower modeled total repayment and shows payments, interest, and year-by-year balances, but excludes fees, escrow costs, mortgage insurance, and adjustable-rate changes.

How the payments are calculated

For each loan, the monthly principal-and-interest payment is:

M = P × r × (1 + r)^n / ((1 + r)^n − 1)

Loan A has a monthly rate of 0.065 ÷ 12 = 0.0054167 and 30 × 12 = 360 payments. Substituting $350,000, 0.0054167, and 360 gives a monthly payment of about $2,212.24. Its modeled total interest is about $446,405.75.

Loan B has a monthly rate of 0.059 ÷ 12 = 0.0049167 and 15 × 12 = 180 payments. The same calculation gives a payment of about $2,934.62 and total interest of about $178,232.30. Its payment is $722.39 higher per month, while its modeled interest is $268,173.45 lower.

The payment-versus-interest tradeoff

A shorter term raises the required payment because the borrower repays principal faster. It also reduces the time interest accrues. Choose based on both the long-run cost and whether the higher payment leaves enough room for other expenses and savings.

Comparison measure Loan A: 30 years at 6.5% Loan B: 15 years at 5.9%
Monthly payment $2,212.24 $2,934.62
Total interest $446,405.75 $178,232.30
Payment difference $722.39 more per month for Loan B
Interest difference $268,173.45 less for Loan B

The rate and term both change between these offers, so this comparison does not isolate the effect of either one. To identify the impact of a rate change, hold the principal and term constant in both loan entries. To compare a refinance or a different principal, include the costs of obtaining the new loan.

What the year-by-year rows show

The balance rows show how much principal remains after each year; the interest rows show interest accrued during that year. These figures help you see when a loan is likely to be paid off and how quickly its balance declines, but the schedule assumes no extra payments, missed payments, or rate changes.

A monthly payment is not the only cost of owning a home. The comparison excludes property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues, lender fees, discount points, and mortgage insurance. Review each lender's Loan Estimate and compare the same cost categories; the CFPB explains how to read that disclosure in its Loan Estimate guide.

When to use a different calculator

A lower modeled total repayment does not automatically make an offer the better choice. Before deciding, compare the required payment, cash needed at closing, lender fees, rate type, mortgage insurance, and the risk that the payment or loan terms may change.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I compare two mortgage offers?

Compare the same loan amount and holding period, then review monthly principal and interest, APR, fees, points, mortgage insurance, and total payments. The CFPB's Loan Estimate guide explains how to compare lender disclosures and identify costs beyond the interest rate.

Should I choose the loan with the lowest total interest?

Not automatically; a shorter-term loan can save interest while requiring a much larger monthly payment. Compare the payment with your budget and cash reserves, and account for fees and the cost of keeping less money available for other needs.

Why can the lower-rate loan cost more overall?

A lower rate can still produce more total interest if the loan amount or repayment term is larger. Compare the principal, rate, and number of payments together rather than using the rate alone.

Does this comparison include closing costs or APR?

No; it compares amortized principal and interest using the entered annual interest rates. It does not include lender fees, discount points, taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, or other costs that can change which offer is cheaper.

What if one loan has an adjustable rate?

This calculator treats each entered rate as fixed for the full term. For an adjustable-rate mortgage, compare the initial rate, adjustment schedule, caps, and possible payment changes using the [Adjustable Rate Mortgage ARM Analyzer](/calculators/adjustable-rate-mortgage-arm-analyzer/).