Contractor vs. Employee Cost Calculator
How to Use This Calculator
- 1
Enter employee count, salary, and benefits burden
Use the Number of Employees, Employee Annual Salary, and Benefits & Overhead Rate fields to estimate annual payroll plus employer costs.
- 2
Enter contractor count, rate, and hours
Use the Number of Contractors, Contractor Hourly Rate, and Contractor Hours per Year fields. Enter expected billable hours per contractor, not automatically 2,080.
- 3
Compare annual totals and per-person costs
Annual Savings shows the absolute difference and identifies the lower-cost group; it does not measure differences in output, risk, or service quality.
Example Calculation
A business compares five employees earning $75,000 each with a 30% benefits burden against three contractors charging $85 per hour for 2,000 hours each.
Number of Employees
5
Employee Annual Salary ($)
75,000
Benefits & Overhead Rate (%)
30
Number of Contractors
3
Contractor Hourly Rate ($/hr)
85
Contractor Hours per Year
2,000
Results
Annual Savings
$22,500
Total Employee Cost
$487,500
Total Contractor Cost
$510,000
Cost per Employee FTE
$97,500
Cost per Contractor
$170,000
Blended Hourly Rate
$60.82
Insights card shows which staffing option has the lower modeled annual cost.
Tips
At 1,500 hours per contractor, contractor cost falls to $382,500
Change Contractor Hours per Year from 2,000 to 1,500. With three contractors at $85 per hour, the annual contractor total becomes $382,500, compared with $487,500 for employees.
A 25% employee burden puts employee cost at $468,750
Change Benefits & Overhead Rate from 30% to 25% to test how a leaner benefits assumption changes the employee side of the comparison.
A 10% contractor rate increase adds $51,000 per year
Change Contractor Hourly Rate from $85 to $93.50 while keeping the hours and contractor count fixed. The total contractor cost rises from $510,000 to $561,000.
What this calculator compares
This calculator compares modeled annual employee compensation costs with contractor fees for the hours entered. It estimates salary plus a benefits-and-overhead percentage against contractor hourly rate multiplied by contractor hours; it does not measure productivity, output quality, tax treatment, or the full cost of managing each arrangement.
How the annual cost is calculated
Total employee cost = Employee count × Annual salary × (1 + Benefits & overhead rate / 100)
Total contractor cost = Contractor count × Hourly rate × Hours per year
Annual savings = Total employee cost − Total contractor cost
Blended hourly rate = (Total employee cost + Total contractor cost) / (Employee hours + Contractor hours)
The calculator treats employee hours as 2,080 per employee per year. A positive savings difference means contractors cost less in this model; a negative difference means employees cost less.
For the example, employee cost is 5 × $75,000 × 1.30 = $487,500. Contractor cost is 3 × $85 × 2,000 = $510,000. The difference is $487,500 − $510,000 = −$22,500, so employees cost $22,500 less. The blended hourly rate is ($487,500 + $510,000) ÷ (5 × 2,080 + 3 × 2,000) = $60.82.
How hours and rates change the comparison
A contractor’s annual cost depends on billable hours as well as the hourly rate. The table changes contractor hours while holding the employee assumptions at five employees, $75,000 salary, and 30% benefits burden.
| Contractor hours each | Total contractor cost | Difference from $487,500 employee cost | Lower modeled cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,500 | $382,500 | Contractors cost $105,000 less | Contractors |
| 1,750 | $446,250 | Contractors cost $41,250 less | Contractors |
| 2,000 | $510,000 | Contractors cost $22,500 more | Employees |
Use expected paid hours, not a full-time assumption, if the work is seasonal or project-based. Then test realistic rates and benefits assumptions. A cost-only comparison does not settle whether an engagement is appropriate: the IRS worker classification guidance explains that federal tax classification depends on the facts of the working relationship.
The benefits percentage is an input rather than a fixed national rate. For context on how employer compensation is divided between wages and benefits, consult the Bureau of Labor Statistics employer costs for employee compensation data, then use figures that match your industry and workforce.
When to use a different calculator
- Estimate benefit costs for employees in more detail → employee benefits cost calculator
- Calculate benefits cost per employee → benefits cost per employee calculator
- Estimate revenue generated per employee → revenue per employee calculator
- Convert a salary to an hourly equivalent → salary-to-hourly wage calculator
Frequently Asked Questions
What costs are included in the employee estimate?
The employee estimate includes salary plus the Benefits & Overhead Rate you enter. It does not itemize health insurance, payroll taxes, retirement contributions, paid leave, recruiting, equipment, or other costs, so include the costs relevant to your comparison in the percentage or in a separate analysis.
Does hiring a contractor always cost less than hiring an employee?
No; contractors can cost more per person or per hour even when they are useful for short-term or specialized work. The result depends on pay, benefits assumptions, contractor rates, and hours, while project management, training, hiring, and continuity costs are outside this calculation.
How many hours count as a full-time equivalent?
This calculator uses 2,080 annual hours for each employee FTE, based on 40 hours per week for 52 weeks. Contractor hours are entered separately, so a contractor working fewer hours is not treated as a full-time engagement.
Can I classify a worker as a contractor to reduce costs?
No; classification depends on the working relationship and applicable law, not on which option is cheaper in this estimate. The IRS independent-contractor guidance explains the federal tax distinction and factors businesses should review.
What should I compare besides annual cost?
Compare the work’s duration, required control, specialized expertise, availability, confidentiality, and the costs of turnover or delayed delivery. The calculator does not score these factors, and federal worker-classification rules can affect whether the contractor option is available.
